40 TVBEurope The Workflow
Fast turnaround workflow for wireless 4K production
Our recent Beyond HD Masters conference at BAFTA demonstrated that there are many hurdles to come in attempting to shoot 4K for fast turnaround broadcast productions. Here, David Fox examines one possible live 4K workflow path
ALTHOUGH IT is possible to do a live production in 4K — as Sony, Telegenic, HBS and FIFA TV demonstrated during the recent Confederations Cup in Brazil, when they covered three live matches in quick succession — it is not simple. There are elements we take for granted in HD, such as wireless links, that don’t yet exist for Ultra HD, while none of the large-sensor cameras are ideally suited to broadcast shooting requirements. However, the combination of
a clever feature in Ross Video’s vision mixers, a ‘zero delay’ HD wireless system and an easy post production workflow could provide a relatively low-cost method of producing fast turnaround productions in 4K that would be particularly suitable for live events, such as concerts, or for studio drama. With so few UHD services in place there is currently little need to transmit 4K live, but live workflows are often the best way to cover an event. So, with no immediate prospect of being able to provide a suitable 4K wireless link, Scott Walker, co- founder of wireless specialists Boxx TV, has come up with a neat solution for enabling cable- free shooting in UHD. “The easiest method is to have
a live-to-media production, where you record native 4K in the camera. You then transport an HD signal, via cable or wireless, and with a Boxx zero delay system there is no difference in timing to the gallery or OB van. The director would use a mixer made by Ross Video that has an ingenious capability that allows you to put timecode into the vision desk that then creates an EDL based on the camera selection. It can then output the EDL on a USB stick.” The LiveEDL edit decision
list feature is available on Ross’ compact CrossOver range as an option, and comes standard on the more extensive Carbonite
Copperhead or wireless via a Boxx TV system with the F55, which can have tally, comms, timecode, reference and sync lock and send an HD feed out for the vision mixer via either system. “The Ross LiveEDL
capability is very exciting, specifically for this type of shooting,” he says. “It will help keep the costs down. If you can record ISO in the camera (on any camera) you only need a main and backup vision mix VT instead of a truck full of them.” Using the F55 with a vision
mixer like this can make it a lot simpler, and cheaper, in post to auto-conform a 4K edit or to stay in the native production format the whole-way through post. Although Badham has
An alternative workflow:
Scott Walker with a Sony F5 4K-capable camera
series “so you can use it with lots of different types of production or budget,” he says. “We sync the cameras to a master clock that is also feeding the vision desk, and we can then walk into an edit suite and quickly create a 4K master of the event. On the day, you’re not recording the 4K out, but the EDL — so every single camera is also ISO recording, which gives you infinite opportunities to make changes in the edit. “It means you can have a
completely wireless studio or shoot a concert, say, in a listed building where it is difficult to go cabled. You can use wireless to get you to a level of production that is very flexible, yet still deliver in 4K.” “The desire is out there” for
4K live production, but “it is not yet being met by the manufacturers,” adds Nick Badham, head of project management, Procam TV, a UK- based hire company that has
worked on shoots with Ross vision mixers, Procam doesn’t have any in its range. However it is considering buying some as part of a new investment in mixers for a wide range of programme production (from
“How come lens and camera manufacturers didn’t think TV OB people would want to use this kit in television set ups?”
Nick Badham, Procam TV
several 4K-capable cameras on its books: the Sony F65, the PMW- F55, PMW-F5 and NEX-FS700, and the Red One MX. All of Procam’s 12 F55s are regularly out, and it is buying more. Badham believes that Walker’s
idea would be suitable for multi- camera shoots with the Sony F55, where the 4K would be recorded in the camera, while an HD signal could be sent wirelessly to the OB truck. Many of Procam’s customers want to do this style of shooting “and to go cable-free is a great advantage.” Procam typically uses fibre, via Telecast Fiber’s
robotic cameras on reality shows to multi-camera corporate shoots and big studio productions), all of which have different requirements “so the final choices have to be carefully made to accommodate all considerations,” he says.
Long and expensive development process Ideally, UHD productions would be able to use 4K wireless links. “However, getting a practical 4K wireless system isn’t so simple, as it’s eight times the bandwidth of current products,” says Walker. Boxx
has done some experiments, but these just show that it will take a long and expensive development process to deliver full UHD mobile links. “One prospect could be to go
to a very high frequency, such as 60GHz, which offers a lot more bandwidth, but the range [carrying distance] is significantly reduced. The other is to multiplex four HD signals together, but the timings required have nanosecond limitations. When transporting 4K, even over four separate BNC cables, it’s important to have those four cables exactly the same length,” he explains. “This is because the timing
differentials between the four signals are extremely small, so when trying to work with these parameters over wireless it adds a whole new level of timing issues that have to be resolved. It would probably require some sort of buffering, which would add at least another frame delay — but it would also require very accurate and fast processing.” 60GHz has about 6GHz of
bandwidth, which is mostly licence exempt (depending on the country). “At the moment, these frequencies are being used for short-haul Ethernet connections. In a line of sight, when you have extremely narrow beam connections, it goes about 4-5km. But, you can’t use a directional antenna off the back of a camera because it’s moving, so it would be sub 50m, which might work in a studio or where you have a tracker running next to a Steadicam operator, but you are certainly not going to see technology at 60GHz to cover a golf course, unless it is used simply for point-to-point links,” adds Walker. “When you are at 60GHz,
there is no loss whatsoever, so the quality is exactly the same as if using a cable.” There is also hardly any delay. Boxx’s current, ‘zero delay’ HD wireless link, Meridian, has a delay of less than one millisecond (less than 1/30th of a frame), but 60GHz is less than 0.000002 milliseconds.
Broadcast facilities Of course, while there is a considerable desire to shoot 4K like this, it will take a while for the talk to translate into productions — but Badham is confident it will. Many directors, typically of music videos or light entertainment, like to shoot on F55s for high-end broadcast work or commercial projects, primarily to get the shallow depth of field and filmic look,
www.tvbeurope.com August 2013
Page 1 |
Page 2 |
Page 3 |
Page 4 |
Page 5 |
Page 6 |
Page 7 |
Page 8 |
Page 9 |
Page 10 |
Page 11 |
Page 12 |
Page 13 |
Page 14 |
Page 15 |
Page 16 |
Page 17 |
Page 18 |
Page 19 |
Page 20 |
Page 21 |
Page 22 |
Page 23 |
Page 24 |
Page 25 |
Page 26 |
Page 27 |
Page 28 |
Page 29 |
Page 30 |
Page 31 |
Page 32 |
Page 33 |
Page 34 |
Page 35 |
Page 36 |
Page 37 |
Page 38 |
Page 39 |
Page 40 |
Page 41 |
Page 42 |
Page 43 |
Page 44 |
Page 45 |
Page 46 |
Page 47 |
Page 48 |
Page 49 |
Page 50 |
Page 51 |
Page 52 |
Page 53 |
Page 54 |
Page 55 |
Page 56 |
Page 57 |
Page 58 |
Page 59 |
Page 60 |
Page 61 |
Page 62 |
Page 63 |
Page 64 |
Page 65 |
Page 66 |
Page 67 |
Page 68