FASHION LAW
Terminating an agency, distribution, or supply agreement? Why it’s important to get it right
A
party seeking to terminate a contract for serious breach can commonly make one or more mistakes, such as misinterpreting a termination clause; incorrectly attempting to rely on the repudiatory – that is serious – breach of the other party; or simply not following the correct termination procedure set out in the contract.
Sometimes this is because there is often confusion between the two main grounds for terminating a contract – contractual termination and termination at common law. Contracts typically confer rights of termination, which specify the circumstances in which one or both parties can terminate the contract. For example, if one party commits a material breach, fails to meet certain contractual milestones, or becomes insolvent. However, under common law, contracts can also be terminated if a serious breach occurs. It is important for the parties under contract to get termination notices right; failure to terminate correctly can mean losing the right to terminate altogether, or even giving the party in breach the right to terminate and claim damages for wrongful termination! And in the case of the termination of an agency agreement, a claim for compensation or indemnity under the Commercial Agents Regulations or the EU Agents Directive. The mistakes and problems that can occur were illustrated in a recent High Court judgement.
Serious breach case examples compared: Topalsson GmbH v Rolls-Royce Motor Cars Ltd A judgment was given recently in a case involving Rolls-Royce Motor Cars (“RRMC”) which serves as a reminder of the principles underpinning termination under English law and the significant consequences of serving defective termination notices. RRMC entered into a supply agreement with Topalsson, a German software company, to supply digital visualisation software for its new model. The agreement included a general timeline for meeting certain milestones and deliverables. A revised, more detailed implementation plan was later agreed between the parties.
42 • FOOTWEAR TODAY • OCTOBER 2023 What to consider on termination?
¡ Is terminating the contract the most appropriate route? Consider whether the other party is able to remedy the breach under the terms of the contract, and if so, be alive to any relevant deadlines. ¡ If you want to terminate the contract, it is essential that you exercise the termination rights correctly in accordance with any relevant termination clauses in the contract: • In what circumstances are you allowed to terminate?
“If you terminate the contract by accepting the serious breach, you may be entitled to seek damages for breach of contract.”
Subsequently, RRMC issued a termination notice on the basis that Topalsson had failed to achieve the original milestones set out in the agreement. Topalsson rejected the termination notice, arguing that the milestones had never been agreed, and affirmed the contract (in other words, treated the contract as continuing). RRMC then sent a second termination notice on the basis that the agreed revised milestones had not been met or, alternatively, that Topalsson’s delay amounted to a serious breach of the agreement. Unsurprisingly, Topalsson again claimed that the second termination notice was invalid. However, this time, Topalsson elected to accept the alleged serious breach, and initiated proceedings against RRMC for wrongful termination.
The Court decided that the first termination notice sent by RRMC relied on erroneous grounds, as the agreement did not contain contractually binding milestones. However, with its second termination notice, RRMC had validly terminated the agreement as the milestones in the revised plan were contractually binding. By choosing to affirm the contract in response to RRMC’s first termination notice, Topalsson had waived RRMC’s breach of invalidly terminating the contract. Therefore, RRMC had managed to evade committing a serious breach itself.
• How much notice must you give? • What procedure must you follow? • To whom should notice of termination be addressed? ¡ What is the correct method of service? ¡ Ensure you communicate your clear intention to terminate the contract through a written notice to the other party, setting out the detailed grounds for termination. ¡ If the other party has committed a serious breach, make sure to act quickly in deciding whether you want to terminate the contract or not:
• If you terminate the contract by accepting the serious breach, you may be entitled to seek damages for breach of contract;
• If you know about the breach and treat the contract as continuing, you will be at risk of affirming the contract (and will consequently lose the right to terminate and claim damages); • But if you terminate a contract incorrectly for serious breach, you could inadvertently commit serious breach and be liable for damages;
• Whether or not a breach amounts to a serious breach will vary on a case-by-case basis.
Stephen Sidkin is a Partner and Jess Howard an Associate at Fox Williams LLP (
www.agentlaw.co.uk;
www.distributorlaw.co.uk;
www.fashionlaw.co.uk;
www.foxwilliams.com)
DOWNLOAD THE FOOTWEAR TODAY APP NOW SPONSORED BY
Page 1 |
Page 2 |
Page 3 |
Page 4 |
Page 5 |
Page 6 |
Page 7 |
Page 8 |
Page 9 |
Page 10 |
Page 11 |
Page 12 |
Page 13 |
Page 14 |
Page 15 |
Page 16 |
Page 17 |
Page 18 |
Page 19 |
Page 20 |
Page 21 |
Page 22 |
Page 23 |
Page 24 |
Page 25 |
Page 26 |
Page 27 |
Page 28 |
Page 29 |
Page 30 |
Page 31 |
Page 32 |
Page 33 |
Page 34 |
Page 35 |
Page 36 |
Page 37 |
Page 38 |
Page 39 |
Page 40 |
Page 41 |
Page 42 |
Page 43 |
Page 44
