HEATING TECHNOLOGY


Incorporating heat pumps into low temperature heat networks


As the UK pushes to decarbonise its heating systems, Paul Longman addresses the challenge of how to effectively integrate heat pumps into heat networks without compromising reliability or comfort for end users, while also addressing the relationship between heat pumps and HIUs.


Paul Longman


National specifications manager Modutherm


www.modutherm.co.uk W


hen looking to supply residential or commercial spaces with heating and hot water, a communal


system (or heat network) is often regarded as the most cost-effective and least carbon-intensive option, compared to multiple individual alternatives. A heat network distributes heat


energy generated from a central location to individual users within a building or buildings. The heat energy is delivered to the end users as low-temperature hot water (LTHW) at < 90°C via a network of pipes. This energy is used to produce domestic hot water and space heating. A well-designed heat network


can deliver both cost and energy savings relative to the installation of multiple localised heat sources. More importantly, heat networks can better facilitate the integration of low carbon and/or renewable heat sources, reducing harmful CO₂ emissions.


Assessing the options So, what are the options available today? Fourth generation heat networks have become prominent, as they can operate at low flow temperatures circa 55-70°C. They enable a more cost-effective transition away from fossil fuels by the greater utilisation of renewables and waste energy to maximise output and minimise carbon emissions. In fact, we have seen significant growth in the number of heat networks incorporating commercial heat pumps on the primary system. These are then connected via the heat network to ‘smart’ heat interface units (HIUs)


EIBI | SEPTEMBER 2024


installed within each apartment. These fourth generation systems


are further supported in the latest revisions to CIBSE’s Guide to Heat Networks (CP1 2020). The document sets the minimum requirement for best practice, as well as guidance on improving overall efficiency. CP1 2020 also focuses on efficiency


at low temperatures caused by the expected rapid increase in the dominance of heat pump technologies. This has led to the recommendation that heat networks should be specified and developed with low-temperature and smart controls in mind. Alternatively, fifth generation


systems reduce flow temperatures further, in most cases, down to ambient. Individual heat pumps are then utilised in dwellings to create heating and DHW. However, ambient systems are not a replacement for fourth generation systems. They are an alternative – especially as they may not be suitable for all projects. For applications with solely apartment buildings, a fourth generation system is usually the best option


Design decisions From a design perspective, many factors affect the network's efficiency. Three key focus points would be: ● Selecting the most efficient


terminal units (such as HIUs with a low VWART). ● Keeping the number of network


bypasses to a minimum. ● Controlling the network pumps


via index located differential pressure sensors, thereby ensuring energy availability across the network. It will also ensure that the turndown ration between peak and ‘idle’ flow is maximised, reducing pump energy use and maximising delta T. Today’s high efficiency pumps can typically operate at less than 10% of their peak flow. It is important that the high network delta T is not ‘wasted’ at the plant room. The hydraulic connections need


to ensure that there is no circulation through the thermal store back to the energy sources and that stratification is occurring. To achieve this, it is recommended that the store is connected in a two-pipe, bi-directional flow arrangement. Thermal storage capacity also


needs to be maximised. This creates flexibility and resilience, and increases the ‘worth’ of the renewable energy sources. On heat pump networks this becomes even more important. Large networks can operate with


significant differential pressures and it is imperative that the HIU control valves are capable of operating, with good authority, against these pressures.


A measure of performance If heat interface units (HIUs) are to be considered heat pump-ready, their efficiency and performance need to be compatible with typical heat pump performance parameters. The HIU will need to produce the required apartment output at the lower network flow temperatures. These lower temperatures would typically result in higher return temperatures and reduced delta T. However, a heat pump ready HIU will be optimised to still deliver a very low return temperature even under these conditions. BESA (British Engineering Services


Association) has created a UK test regime for HIUs that calculates a particular HIU’s efficiency (or VWART). This single value shows the expected annual average return temperature from a particular HIU installed on a heat network. The lower this figure, the more efficient the HIU and the larger the


An efficient heat interface unit (HIU) is critical to the performance of a low temperature heat network


network delta T will be. This reduces network flow rates and annual volumes while delivering the same kW delivery. This allows smaller pumps, pipes, fittings and valves to be used, reduces network losses and pump energy use, lowering capital and operating expenditure. At Modutherm, our MTA PLUS TWIN HIU achieved top marks in the BESA standard, registering the lowest VWART tests of any heat interface unit, with values of 26 (high) and 24 (low) respectively.


Mix and match Optimal heat network efficiency will only be achieved with careful and correct matching of the heat pumps, thermal store(s) and HIUs. It should be remembered that much of the network delta T will be dictated by the HIU and that different units can give rise to widely different delta T’s. A manufacturer that knows its


products can advise on the achievable network return temperature and required flow rate to achieve the peak network demand. The heat pump manufacturer can then calculate the recommended thermal store size for their heat pumps So, there are many factors to


consider when incorporating heat pumps into low temperature heat networks. Not only do HIUs need to be compatible but they need to produce return temperatures as low as possible. Thankfully, by selecting the best-performing HIUs on the market, truly decarbonised heat networks remain firmly within specifiers’ and contractors’ reach. ■


25


Page 1  |  Page 2  |  Page 3  |  Page 4  |  Page 5  |  Page 6  |  Page 7  |  Page 8  |  Page 9  |  Page 10  |  Page 11  |  Page 12  |  Page 13  |  Page 14  |  Page 15  |  Page 16  |  Page 17  |  Page 18  |  Page 19  |  Page 20  |  Page 21  |  Page 22  |  Page 23  |  Page 24  |  Page 25  |  Page 26  |  Page 27  |  Page 28  |  Page 29  |  Page 30  |  Page 31  |  Page 32  |  Page 33  |  Page 34  |  Page 35  |  Page 36  |  Page 37  |  Page 38  |  Page 39  |  Page 40  |  Page 41  |  Page 42  |  Page 43  |  Page 44