New uses for fossil assets |
Figure 4. New molten salt steam energy storage system at Alba, Chile. Coal handling, boiler and pollutant control systems (left) are removed, but the remaining plant is refitted with molten salt units
(Image PP B Jensen, H A Soliman, Aalborg CSP can retrofit coal plants into thermal energy storage, redrawn by ICSC, source
https://helioscsp.com/ aalborg-csp-can-retrofit-coal-plants-into-thermal-energy-storage/, Solar Thermal Energy News HeliScsp, vp (Feb 2021))
In China, mixed generation sites are under development based on high efficiency coal power stations, with energy storage provided by batteries and hydrogen intended to permit optimum operation of the total system. The net renewables capacity is designed to match the coal station contribution, so in the latest project, at Ordos, Inner Mongolia, nominal 12 GW of solar and wind is designed to operate with a 4 GW coal power system. China is the international leader in implementing new wind and solar farms, but also intends to use coal, a cheap domestically supplied fuel, and this hub design is intended to lower overall CO2
emissions per MW generated
from the whole facility, although it doesn’t eliminate CO2
CCS system is applied.
New battery installations now dominate the energy storage sector, attracting most investment, with the global battery market exceeding $100 billion/y. Locating large battery storage plants at former coal power stations allows use of existing transformers and connectivity to the grid, key barriers to adding new renewable sources. The preferred technology is high energy density lithium, the lightest metal. Lithium is the subject of supply concern and there is considerable research focus on alternate chemistries that can reduce reliance on critical elements.
One issue for batteries is that they can only supply power at the 100 MW level for periods of several hours, inadequate to cover prolonged low renewables generation but effective in supporting peak demand. New flow battery plants, located at former power plants, use base metals such as iron and aim to supply lower power levels, typically around 10 MW, but for periods of weeks. They may be ideal for lower density populations.
emissions from coal unless a
One high-capacity system that can make use of much of the equipment in an existing coal station, especially the steam turbine installation, is thermal salt energy storage. A hot salt reservoir provides high thermal capacity, with the heat then applied to drive a steam system and turbine, providing energy equivalent to a power plant for up to 12 hours or more. The salt is heated electrically by renewables and can act as a swing power source with a solar farm to maintain supply during the night, see Figure 4. A hot salt steam system can outperform a battery plant in terms of maximum power supply and duration. This would be especially suitable for repurposing newer installations where expensive sections of a former coal plant, including turbines, can be reassigned for this technology. Originally conceived to augment a coal station, the technology has been re-envisaged as a standalone energy storage system.
The nuclear option
Conventional nuclear stations provide critical dispatchable power, but costs are high, and the scale of 3 to 4 GW doesn’t match regional demand that would complement distributed renewables supply. Compact small modular reactors (SMRs) are seen to bridge the gap with mass production viewed as a route to lower cost nuclear power, as opposed to constructing large one-off bespoke installations. The output of SMRs is typically 400 MW, which matches the capacity of older coal stations and derives an economic benefit by locating at coal plant sites incorporating existing facilities that include cooling systems and grid connectivity. There continues to be concern over radioactive waste, safety, and security. Reactors at 1/10th scale are inherently safer but radioactive waste is assessed as being proportionally greater for
small devices. However, there is existing ‘proof of concept’ as SMRs are already deployed in ships and submarines, and electron beam welding methods may reduce reactor cost and improve durability. Where higher output is needed, then sets of four or six SMRs are proposed, as recently in Romania and the UK, but they require bespoke infrastructure.
Prospects
Former coal sites have attractive attributes to support the energy transition, including their location, connectivity and support facilities that can be valuable to new projects. Renewable generation is ironically supported by flexing fossil power plants, but as these are withdrawn then support of electricity grids becomes a pressing issue. The urgent need for energy storage has led to a complete revaluation of former coal sites; former coal mines could offer solutions involving potential energy, using air, water and gravity, as well as geothermal energy based heat pump systems.
Coal stations have valuable grid connections, and the latter are proving to be a key barrier to new renewable energy plants. Coal plant sites can house large battery installations or be developed into energy hubs that even retain the coal boiler, possibly refuelled with natural gas or biomass. Battery installations pose significant demand for critical elements that are in short supply, and alternatives based upon potential energy storage reduce this economic risk. SMR nuclear projects are selecting coal sites for a rapidly developing new dispatchable-power industry. Previously, the fate of coal plants was simply to scrap them and for closing mines to commence restoration, but the realisation that there is an urgent need for energy storage and base power generation is changing perceptions.
This article is based on the report Repurposing coal assets by Dr Ian Reid, ICSC/3298, London, UK, International Centre for Sustainable Carbon, 85pp (Oct 2023) available from the ICSC website
https://www.sustainable-carbon.org/
14 | April 2024|
www.modernpowersystems.com
Page 1 |
Page 2 |
Page 3 |
Page 4 |
Page 5 |
Page 6 |
Page 7 |
Page 8 |
Page 9 |
Page 10 |
Page 11 |
Page 12 |
Page 13 |
Page 14 |
Page 15 |
Page 16 |
Page 17 |
Page 18 |
Page 19 |
Page 20 |
Page 21 |
Page 22 |
Page 23 |
Page 24 |
Page 25 |
Page 26 |
Page 27 |
Page 28 |
Page 29 |
Page 30 |
Page 31 |
Page 32 |
Page 33 |
Page 34 |
Page 35 |
Page 36 |
Page 37 |
Page 38 |
Page 39 |
Page 40 |
Page 41 |
Page 42 |
Page 43