This page contains a Flash digital edition of a book.
THE Circuit, Division I


by stephen r. leFFler & deAn decAndIA


RCOURT EPORT


CIRCUIT COURT—November 2012 through March 2013 COURT


JUDGE VERDICT McCarroll


1. Sneh Bhatnagar v. Memphis Radiological, P.C., December 5, 2012, Med Mal, Richard Glassman for Plaintiff, Andrea Malkin and Jerry Mitchell for Defendant, Defense verdict


2. Debbie Griffin v. Heather Renner, January 23, 2013, Auto Accident, John P. Wade for Plaintiff, Phil Bass for Defendant, Plaintiff verdict for $48,352.62 (Reduced by 49% comparative fault)


3. Juan Reyes v. Elizabeth Boyd, March 20, 2013, Auto Accident, Tressa Johnson and Kristy Bennett for Plaintiff, Dawn Carson, for Defendant, Plaintiff Verdict for $3,449 (Reduced by 30% comparative fault


4. Derek Jones v. Elizabeth Boyd, March 21, 2013, Auto Accident, Tressa Johnson and Kristy Bennett for Plaintiff, Dawn Carson for Defendant, Plaintiff Verdict for $12,707 (Reduced by 30% comparative fault )


Circuit, Division II Russell Circuit, Division III Williams Circuit, Division IV Higgins No jury cases this reporting period


1. La Rhonda Graves v. Methodist Hospital, February 13, 2013, Med Mal, Bill Walk and Regina Guy for Plaintiff, Bill Bomar and Rob Hale for Defendant, Mistrial (Second Mistrial)


2. Amos Goostree v. Maurice White, March 21, 2013, Auto accident, David Gordon for Plaintiff, Chris Marshburn for Defendant, Defense Verdict


1. Fred Jones v. Carmisha Nelson, November 28, 2012, Auto Accident , Valerie Smith for Plaintiff, Toof Brown for Defendant, Dawn Carson for John Doe, Plaintiff Verdict for $16,340.00 (80% fault to Defendant, 20% fault to John Doe)


2. Robyn Mellow v. Estate of Robbie T. Shaw, February 13, 2013, Auto Accident , Jeff Rosenblum for Plaintiff, Garrett Estep for Defendant, Plaintiff Verdict for $190,000.00


3. Vercelia Brown v. Perry Easterwood, February 20, 2013, Auto Accident , Ronald Lucchesi for Plaintiff, Matthew Russell for Defendant, Plaintiff Verdict for $22,000.00


4. Linda Foster v. Caitlyn Bailey, March 20, 2013, Auto Accident, Leonard Van Eaton for Plaintiff, Craig Flood for Defendant, Defense Verdict (50/50 fault)


Circuit, Division V Robilio


1. Lakesha Davis v. Ronald Brotherton, January 30, 2013, Auto Accident, Latrina Ingram and Vernita Martin for Plaintiff, Melanie Stewart for Defendant, Defense Verdict


2. Amber Pairmore v. Patricia Baskin, January 23, 2013, Auto Accident, Martin Kriger for Plaintiff, Chris Marshburn for Defendant, Plaintiff Verdict for $1,686.27


3. Christina Nichols v. Dan H. Shell III, M.D., February 13, 2013, Med Mal, Gary Smith for Plaintiff, J. Kimbrough Johnson for Defendant, Mistrial.


4. Phshawn Watts v. Camelia Boyland, March 19, 2013, Auto Accident, Shannon Elsea for Plaintiff, Robert Gatewood for Defendant, Defense Verdict


Circuit, Division VI Stokes


1. Tomas Roush v. Kirk Swindle, Jr., December 4, 2012, Auto Accident, Ben Taylor for Plaintiff, H. Lynne Smith for Defendant, Verdict for Plaintiff for $50,000


2. Vicky Lynn Scott v. Shantelle Kirkland d/b/a Picky Perfectshum, December 10, 2012, Auto Accident, Linley Richter for Plaintiff, Christopher Vescovo for Defendant, Defense Verdict


3. David Berger and Amanda Berger vCathy Chapman, M.D., January 18, 2013, Med Mal, John Price and Bradley Cordts for Plaintiff, Darrell Baker, J. Kimbrough Johnson and Jim Wilson for Defendant, Defense verdict


4. Charles Spencer v. Paul Hyde, January 23, 2013, Auto Accident, Derrick Fairchilds for Plaintiff, William Jeter for Defendant, Plaintiff verdict $50,000


5. James Collier v. Kim Kopischke, January 29, 2013, Auto Accident, James Blount for Plaintiff, Robert Moore for Defendant, Plaintiff Verdict $25,000


6. Chantel Bonds v. Barbara Scheirer, February 5, 2013, Auto Accident, Mike Long for Plaintiff, Candace Hargett for Defendant, Defense Verdict


24


Page 1  |  Page 2  |  Page 3  |  Page 4  |  Page 5  |  Page 6  |  Page 7  |  Page 8  |  Page 9  |  Page 10  |  Page 11  |  Page 12  |  Page 13  |  Page 14  |  Page 15  |  Page 16  |  Page 17  |  Page 18  |  Page 19  |  Page 20  |  Page 21  |  Page 22  |  Page 23  |  Page 24  |  Page 25  |  Page 26  |  Page 27  |  Page 28  |  Page 29  |  Page 30  |  Page 31  |  Page 32  |  Page 33  |  Page 34  |  Page 35  |  Page 36