Rail Professional opinion Katie Silvester, editor


Fare game? Peak prices can’t rise


The delayed command paper containing the government’s response to the McNulty report has been released (see news story on opposite page and Wright Track, pages 18-19). The national press honed in on the comments about fares, particularly as the possibility of raising some peak time fares is mentioned. This would


be offset by measures such as offering cheaper season tickets both to those who work part time and those who are able to travel during what is sometimes called the ‘shoulders’ of the peak – in other words, still travelling between 07:00 -10:000 in the morning and 16:00-19:00 in the evening, but avoiding the very busiest trains. There is to be a separate review of ticketing before any decisions are made


about fare changes. But it is safe to say that further raising of peak fares will be extremely unpopular. Raising fares on the most overcrowded trains would effectively penalise commuters for, as the command paper puts it, driving ‘the need for capacity enhancements by travelling at the busiest times’. Since the most overcrowded trains in the country are those that go in and out of London during the peak, it would effectively mean putting up the fares on the most expensive routes anyway. By way of comparison, a single fare from Reading to London, arriving before 09:00 is £20.60. A single ticket from Darlington to Newcastle, also arriving before 09:00, is £8.90. ‘But we travel on older, more uncomfortable rolling stock,’ a northern commuter would probably say, to justify the price difference. ‘Well I spend the entire journey crammed into a vestibule with many others – I’ve never sat on a seat!’ a Reading-based commuter would probably counter. (See pages 26-27 for commuters comments about the horrors of First Great Western’s peak services into London). The fares review needs to carefully consider regional differences in prices. What


the government sees as some kind of a ‘supplement’ to travel on the most popular services, commuters will see as pricing people off the railways. Those travelling in the south-east of England will again want to ask why they pay so much more than their northern counterparts for journeys at any time of day, which is largely a historical anomaly, rather than a genuine reflection of the quality of the trains. There is some good news on fares in the command paper, however, including the


idea of different types of season tickets, or carnets, for part-time workers or those who work non-standard hours. At the moment commuters who only travel two or three days a week often have little option but to queue up each time to buy an Anytime return ticket, with none of the discounts available to their full-time colleagues. The intention to end annual increases above the rate of inflation is also stated


in the paper – and it will be welcomed by passengers. The above-inflation rises that we have seen for the last 10 years came about as a result of a decision, by the then- Labour government, that further investment was needed in the railways and that passengers ought to part finance it. This is where Britain is so out of step with most other European countries, where railways are seen as a public service funded mainly out of general taxation, with fares kept at a more affordable level. Naturally the investment that has gone into the railways has been very beneficial. But charging ever higher fares, when the UK is already the most expensive place in Europe to travel by rail, is not the right way to do it.


PAGE 4 APRIL 2012


News in brief


BAA rebrands Heathrow Express


Heathrow Express, which is owned by BAA, has invested £16m in a rebrand that will see new corporate colours, new staff uniforms and refurbished rolling stock. It will be rolled out from the end of April when the rolling stock will begin re-entering service.


Tube reliability peaks


London Underground is on course for its most reliable year since TfL took responsibility for the tube 10 years ago. The latest performance figures show passenger numbers at their highest and average delays the lowest since 2003-04. London mayor Boris Johnson said it was due to co-operation between engineers and officials.


Pensions row


RMT members are being balloted for possible industrial action over pensions. The issue surrounds those working for Tube Lines, including ex-Alstom Stratford Market depot staff, to become members of the TfL pension scheme. The union is also demanding the same travel concessions as those employed by London Underground, which ex-Metronet workers receive.


Emergency planning course launches


The University of Wolverhampton has launched a postgraduate certificate in the Management of Passenger Transport Emergency Incidents, aimed at transport professionals and the emergency services.


Cyclists to get new facility at Cambridge


Cambridge station is to get 3,000 new cycle parking spaces, in the form of a CyclePoint, with facilities for repair, hire and cycle sales. It is being funded by the DfT and developer Brookgate, as part of a wider station upgrade. Chelmsford will get a smaller CyclePoint, funded by the DfT, Essex County Council and Greater Anglia.


Page 1  |  Page 2  |  Page 3  |  Page 4  |  Page 5  |  Page 6  |  Page 7  |  Page 8  |  Page 9  |  Page 10  |  Page 11  |  Page 12  |  Page 13  |  Page 14  |  Page 15  |  Page 16  |  Page 17  |  Page 18  |  Page 19  |  Page 20  |  Page 21  |  Page 22  |  Page 23  |  Page 24  |  Page 25  |  Page 26  |  Page 27  |  Page 28  |  Page 29  |  Page 30  |  Page 31  |  Page 32  |  Page 33  |  Page 34  |  Page 35  |  Page 36  |  Page 37  |  Page 38  |  Page 39  |  Page 40