Growers pin hopes on Columbia River update Compensation for greater US competition a key issue for fruit and vegetable growers


KELOWNA – Negotiations to update the 55-year-old Columbia River Treaty between Canada and the US are ramping up. Ratified in 1964, the treaty’s main purpose was to optimise power generation and flood control for both Canada and the US. Three dams were constructed in Canada: Duncan in 1967, Arrow/Hugh Keenleyside in 1968 and Mica in 1973. Canadian land was set aside for a reservoir when the US built Libby dam in Montana in 1972. Canada manages 15.5-million-acre feet of water a year to help both Canadian and US utilities gain optimum power generation and lessen the potential for floods. “Power and flood control

were the only items of importance in the day,” Kathy Eichenberger, executive director of the BC Columbia River Treaty Review, told a recent meeting of the Okanagan Basin Water Board. The treaty benefits the US

by managing river flows, which helps control flooding, manage power generation potential, maintain navigation conditions, enhance fisheries and provides late season irrigation and recreation opportunities. BC receives an entitlement to sell power on the open market, worth $180 million last year, as well as increased power generation capacity. The Revelstoke dam, for instance, could not have been built if the Mica dam hadn’t been built first.

But BC lost a lot – more

than 600 square kilometres of fertile bottom land was flooded, 2,300 people were relocated, entire communities were displaced, and First Nations cultural sites were lost. Fluctuating water levels have a significant impact on communities alongside the reservoirs the dams created. Nakusp residents, for example, have to deal with a 20-metre change in lake levels that make it tough to establish docking facilities. Moreover, BC citizens were

not consulted in the initial treaty process.


That changed in 2014, when the BC government made the decision to continue the treaty and seek improvements within the existing framework. A review over the last three years included community meetings in Nelson, Castlegar, Trail, Cranbrook, Jaffray, Invermere, Golden, Revelstoke Nakusp and Fauquier. There is on-going consultation with the three First Nations in the region and Eichenberger says they’ll return to the other 10 communities that hosted meetings. She says the top two negotiation issues for BC are “clear gains over the status quo regarding economic, social, environmental and Indigenous interests and economic return of [an] equitable share of all US benefits.” “The true value of the

treaty to the US is much more than power and flood control,” she says. “That needs to be recognized by the US.”

BC fruit, potato and onion

growers face stiff competition from US producers who are able to pump water out of Lake Roosevelt and irrigate land that only receives five to eight inches of rain a year. “That irrigation water

allowed growers to switch from dry land farming of oats, barley and sugar beets to fruit trees, asparagus and onions,” noted Adrian Arts, a young orchardist from Summerland. “I’ve been on a 1,000-acre orchard down there. You can see these huge swathes of green in between the dry sagebrush.” The key to this orchard success is flow timing. While the Grand Coulee dam was constructed before the Columbia River treaty, Canadian water management ensures late summer and early fall flows provide enough water to finish the irrigation season and prepare the thousands of acres of fruit trees in the area for the winter. As well, flow management

provides water for spawning fish.

The true value of this water

is hard to measure, however. Calculating that benefit, and the potential for increased economic benefit going forward, will be challenging.

Methodology BC Fruit Growers

Association general manager Glen Lucas has been gathering background on the economic benefits of shaping the water flow. “That has not been a hard sell because the US has done an irrigation study and they know,” says Lucas. “But we need to come up with a methodology to determine how that shaping of the water flow benefits agriculture.” “We know that

conversation is coming,” says Eichenberger. “We are far apart, but collaboration seems to be the tone.” There have been four negotiation sessions to date. A fifth is scheduled for late February.

There is some urgency on the US side. The agreement to manage flows for flood control expires in 2024. After that, Canada no longer has to provide assured storage and the US must use their own storage capacity first before Canada can be “called upon” (as the treaty describes it). That means the current flow patterns for power, fish, recreation and agriculture could be completely disrupted. “The US Army Corps of

Engineers is very concerned about this,” says Eichenberger, noting that the window doesn’t leave enough time to build more flood control capacity. “If we don’t agree on something, they are going to be in a very difficult situation.” Washington famers might add to that urgency. Some very productive farmland sits outside the Columbia Basin. Up until now, they have relied on deep wells, and those wells are running dry. They are licking their lips as they look towards Lake Roosevelt.

Flotation Tires to replace

11R22.5 Tires or Silage Boxes



Under the Water Sustainability Act, ALL groundwater wells used for any purpose other than single family household domestic use require a licence. Apply before March 1, 2019 to avoid fees and secure water rights.

Need help submitting the application? Ask us!

1-844-585-0802 (Toll Free) 250-585-0802 (Direct)

Lower Mainland, Vancouver Island, Okanagan, & the Cariboo

Floor Chain Assemblies for all makes of Forage and Manure Boxes

Scale Repairs

for ALL Makes of Feeder Mixers


Fittings, Pipe Fittings, and

Pressure Washer Accessories

3000 Gallon Manure Tank 10,, Boom, Dual Pumps,

Flotation Tires, Single Axle $77,500.00


Hydraulic Hose

Repairs RENT OUR

Loewen 925 cubic foot 20ft. Forage Box $500/day

Hubs, Spindles, Tires & Wheels

for Artex, Dirks and TyCrop Wagons

Hydump Cylinders

3 Point Hitch - Size: 18-30, lg. Lagoon Style - Size: 30-40, lg. Slotted Floor Barn

Manure Agitators

We sell knives for Supreme, Trioliet, Jaylor and Kuhn Vertical Mixers. We also carry Interstate Batteries and Lite kits for farm machinery.

Page 1  |  Page 2  |  Page 3  |  Page 4  |  Page 5  |  Page 6  |  Page 7  |  Page 8  |  Page 9  |  Page 10  |  Page 11  |  Page 12  |  Page 13  |  Page 14  |  Page 15  |  Page 16  |  Page 17  |  Page 18  |  Page 19  |  Page 20  |  Page 21  |  Page 22  |  Page 23  |  Page 24  |  Page 25  |  Page 26  |  Page 27  |  Page 28  |  Page 29  |  Page 30  |  Page 31  |  Page 32  |  Page 33  |  Page 34  |  Page 35  |  Page 36  |  Page 37  |  Page 38  |  Page 39  |  Page 40  |  Page 41  |  Page 42  |  Page 43  |  Page 44  |  Page 45  |  Page 46  |  Page 47